Is Uttarakhand Cadre good for IAS officers

Difference between IAS and IPS

IAS and IPS are the two most challenging jobs in India that not only confer power and position, but also have certain duties to the nation and responsibilities to society. The Indian Administrative Service (IAS) is considered the highest public service job offered to candidates leading the public service exam.

The best alternative according to IAS is that Indian Police Service (IPS), which is a dream job for many Indian citizens too, but it is a technical job that requires maintaining peace and order in the state and direct interaction with anti-social elements.

The civil service exam is the toughest exam conducted in India in three stages, that is, the preliminary exam, the main exam and the interview by the Union Public Service Commission. It recruits various civil servants for the various positions in government departments including the Indian Administrative Service (IAS), Indian Police Service (IPS), Indian Engineering Service (IES), Indian Overseas Service (IFS), etc.

The article excerpt will help you understand the difference between IAS and IPS.

Comparison table

Basis of comparisonIASIPS
importanceAn IAS refers to the major public services in India that operate as the administrative arm of All India Services.An IPS includes the protective arm of All India Services, whose cadre is taken over by both the central government and the state government.
roleAn IAS officer is responsible for the public administration as well as for the formulation and implementation of the guidelines.An IPS officer is responsible for maintaining law and order, as well as for preventing and investing crime in the area.
Allocation to candidatesThe candidates who top the public service exam.After an IAS is appointed, the other top holders are promoted to IPS.
Training academyLal Bahadur Shastri National Academy of Administration, Mussorie, Uttarakhand.National Police Academy Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel, Hyderabad, Telangana.
Cadre Control AuthorityDepartment of Personnel and Training, Ministry of Personnel, Complaints and Pension.Ministry of Interior, Government of India.
DepartmentsAn IAS employee works in several government departments and ministries.An IPS officer works in the police department.
wagesHighComparatively low
Number of officers in an areaAMore than one
Rank in the hierarchyTopAccording to IAS

About IAS

IAS stands for Indian Administrative Service, formerly known as Imperial Civil Service, is the bureaucratic wing of All India Services. A person can become an IAS by not only qualifying the public service exam but also getting a top rank. The review is carried out every year by the Union Public Service Commission (UPSC).

If a candidate qualifies for the IAS exams, he / she will be appointed as a subdivision judge for the probationary period. After this period, the officer is promoted to a district judge and collector for a number of years, after which the officer takes on the role of division commissioner who heads the entire department of the state. An IAS officer may also serve as the central secretary, additional secretary, secretary and cabinet secretary at the top level of central government.

The main tasks of an IAS officer are the formulation of guidelines and their implementation, public administration, secretarial management and so on. An IAS officer is responsible for collecting revenue and, like courts, works to resolve revenue issues. He is also responsible for the implementation of the guidelines formulated by the center and the state.

About IPS

Indian Police Service (IPS), formerly known as Indian Imperial Police, is the senior policeman in the Police Department. An IPS officer is a qualified community service aspirant who serves the nation by directing the police force at both the state and central levels.

An IPS officer is also the leader and commander of the Indian intelligence services and central police organizations, such as B. Intelligence Bureau (IB), Central Reserve Police Force (CRPF), Border Security Forces (BSF), Central Investigation Bureau (CBI), Research and Analysis Branch (RAW), National Security Gaurd, Vigilance Organization, etc.

The basic duties of an IPS officer include law enforcement, public order, criminal investigation and security. The Ministry of the Interior (MHS) takes care of its cadre management as well as political decisions regarding the cadre structure, hiring, appointment, representation, salary, allowances and ancillary costs etc.

Main differences between IAS and IPS

The difference between IAS and IPS can be made clear for the following reasons:

  1. IAS, or otherwise known as Indian Administrative Services, is the premier public service that functions as the administrative wing of All India Services (AIS). In contrast, IPS stands for Indian Police Service, one of the three branches of All India Services, the cadre of which is appointed by both headquarters and the states.
  2. An IAS officer deals with public administration and the formulation and implementation of guidelines after discussing it with the minister of the relevant department. Conversely, an IPS officer takes care of law and order in the area in which he / she is posted. At the same time, he / she is also responsible for the investigation, detection and prevention of criminal offenses in this area
  3. IAS is the first choice for most civil service aspirants, as well as the senior exam holders who are appointed as IAS, while the second highly preferred alternative is the IPS and will be the next front runner after the appointment of the IAS officer as IPS Officer hired.
  4. The training to become an IAS officer takes place at the National Academy for Administration Lal Bahadur Shastri, Mussoorie, Uttarakhand. On the other hand, the IPS officers are trained in the Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel National Police Academy, Hyderabad, Telangana.
  5. The Cadre Controlling Authority of IAS is the Department of Personnel and Training, the Department of Personnel, Public Complaints and Pensions. On the contrary, Ministry of Interior, Government of India is the IPS Cadre Controlling Authority.
  6. While an IPS officer works in the police station, an IAS officer is given the opportunity to work with various government departments and ministries.
  7. When it comes to salaries, the salary of an IAS officer is comparatively higher than that of an IPS officer.
  8. There is only one IAS officer in an area. However, the number of IPS officers in an area may vary depending on the crime rate and district in the district.
  9. The IAS officer is superior to an IPS officer as an IPS officer reports to the region's IAS.


The admission criteria are the same for both positions, meaning the candidate must be an Indian citizen, have graduated from an accredited university and have reached the age of 21.

On the whole, both of these posts are very inspiring as they both encourage you to serve your nation. Every year, student lakks perform for the UPSC exam and study around the clock to become IAS or IPS officers. These titles not only have power and authority, but also give recognition and respect in society.