How do you feel about animal rights

Animal Law and Animal Rights - About dealing with animals

FAQ: Animal Law

What rights do animals have?

According to the law, animals are not considered things and enjoy special protection.

What should you watch out for when dealing with animals?

From a legal point of view, aspects of animal welfare, the requirements for keeping animals as appropriate to the species as possible and the liability of animal owners play an important role.

Can animals enforce their rights?

No, because for a judge in court to decide on a possible violation of the law, the lawsuit must be initiated by a legal person.

Legal regulations on animals

The 90th paragraph of the Civil Code reflects the ambivalent legal situation for animal rights in Germany:

Animals are not things. They are protected by special laws. On them they are applicable regulations for things apply accordingly, unless otherwise specified. (Source: § 90a BGB)

On the one hand, animals should have rights that are in "Special laws" are regulated. On the other hand, the rules for things apply. In most cases, however, the Animal Welfare Act applies, as many processes are defined in it. Nevertheless, according to legal experts, the mentioned paragraph has little to no value for animal welfare or the enforcement of Animal rights.

This circumstance affects many Animal rights advocates and friends of course pissed off. In this guide we show you Animal rights on and shed light on aspects of animal law in order to address this difference make clear. We also clarify whether there is something like a Specialist lawyer for animal law whether people with a heart for animals can do more than donate to Peta or other organizations.

Are you looking for an animal rights attorney? In this overview you will find numerous animal law firms!

More guides on animal law

Animal rights: ethics on the one hand, political reality on the other

The Animal welfare has only been in legal texts since relatively short time significant. The "Maliciously torturing or mistreating" animals, "in public or in an annoying manner", was already 1871 made a criminal offense in the Reich Criminal Code. However, it can easily be seen that here not that caused suffering of a living being was in the foreground, but the well-being of the people who were exposed to this suffering as spectators.

The national socialist Legislation postulated for the first time Animal rights, although here of course the Discrediting of Jewish citizens was in the foreground. Because on the one hand, the Jewish faith prescribes the ritual practice of bleeding unaesthetized livestock (slaughter) and on the other hand led supposedly primarily Jews businesses and shops for fur trade. In addition, the National Socialists shifted the relationship between humans and animals by giving their fellow creatures more rights in some cases.

The Federal Republic of Germany issued on July 24, 1972 the Animal Welfare Act. In addition, the federal states can issue rules and regulations that define animal rights more precisely.

Only on July 26, 2002 however, these animal rights were formally im Basic Law (GG) anchored. In order to achieve this, the Bundestag, with the consent of the Bundesrat, ordered Article 20a of the Basic Law to include the three words "And the animals" is supplemented. This is now as follows:

The state also takes responsibility for protecting the natural foundations of life for future generations and the animals within the framework of the constitutional order through the legislature and in accordance with the law and justice through the executive and the judiciary.

(Source: § 20a GG)

So it should be noted that animal rights are more of an issue ethical-philosophical nature which is only slowly gaining a foothold in legislation. This is economically how cultural to explain.

If you look at the History of the people From the animal point of view, it will quickly be noticed that the “crown of creation” is taking its environment and the animals with all their might subject Has. This ruthless Submission and utilization is, in combination with its unusual adaptability, a cornerstone of human success.

But in our modern times the question arises to what extent the Exploitation of nature and oppression of fellow creatures is still justified.

Out economic point of view it must be established that the increased demand for meat and others animal products can only be met if any Animal rights not included become. Because such would be with the usual today Factory farming simply not compatible.

To this day, cows, pigs, chickens and other farm animals are only kept and killed in morally justifiable circumstances if these creatures are seen little or no capacity to suffer ascribes.

Today will not only be in the Food production disregards the moral rights of animals that they may be entitled to. In the medical research are Animal testing established practice. And in circus Elephants, lions and other exotic animals are trained for the amusement of the audience and used as an entertainment factor without giving you a break Right to self-determination to admit.

Nevertheless, it cannot be said that our animal friends are completely without rights, but what rights do animals really have?

More guides on traveling with animals

Do animals have rights?

From a legal point of view, animal rights do not exist because they no legal persons could be. According to the paragraphs quoted above, they are not things either, but they do not have any rights in the sense that these enforceable in court would be. The Animal Welfare Act states that no one “may inflict pain, suffering or harm on an animal without a reasonable reason” (source: § 1 TierSchG), but they let themselves in "Reasonable reason" recognize in many actions.

Animal experiments, circus missions, slaughter for religious reasons, etc. are just a few examples that show how animal rights are in Germany.

"Animals have rights!" chant angry animal rights activists and draw attention to this, in your eyes unacceptable, grievance. Consistent animal rights activists even demand "Human Rights for Animals" and want through abolitionism the vegan diet make it socially dominant.


This extreme form of Animal rights movement rejects any use and ownership that puts humans above animals. Because sentient beings should in the eyes of activists not as property of another can be viewed.

These movements are of course in the minority, but Peta and other animal rights organizations have grown steadily in Germany in recent years. They are mainly financed by donations.

Animal Law: Specialized Articles and Regulations

Next to the Animal welfare law, which defines certain animal rights in the Animal Welfare Act, there is still that Animal law, which specifies in various legal texts, such as with Animals as property has to be dealt with in different situations.

So it is not regulated when animal experiments are allowed, or that fellow creatures should be treated properly by humans. Rather, the focus is on how that Buy or sell, the Import and export, as well as the Accommodation or maintenance this living being has to take place.

Of course there is specialized lawyers in animal law. Such a lawyer is familiar with special paragraphs and ordinances that focus on pets or farm animals, even in the subordinate clause.

This includes, for example Animal owner liability (§ 833 BGB); Animals in road traffic (§ 28 StVO) or that Keeping dangerous animals (§121 OWiG). An animal law attorney can evaluate such paragraphs on a case-by-case basis.

More advice on animal law

Animal law in Switzerland

Also in other European countries Similar ambivalent legislation applies as in Germany. As an example, we will briefly want the Animal rights situation in Switzerland explain, which prides itself on having a particularly comprehensive animal welfare law that regulates people accordingly when dealing with animals.

Here, too, applies that Animals no things are. Still, a Animal Law Lawyer not much can do when an animal is killed, for example. Because a Basic right to life this does not apply here either. Analogous to Germany, the animal rights in Switzerland contain the principle that a non-human living being does not tormented for no reason may be.

Animal experiments are particularly strictly regulated. Every attempt must be submitted to a cantonal “animal experiment commission” and allowed.

(61 Ratings, average: 3,70 of 5)
Animal Law and Animal Rights - About dealing with animals
3.7561Loading ...